Call 24/7 at (954) 761-4011
What Does it Mean to Withhold Adjudication in Florida Criminal Cases?
When facing criminal charges in Florida, you may hear your Fort Lauderdale defense attorney mention “withholding adjudication” as a possible outcome. While this legal concept can significantly impact your future, many defendants don’t fully understand what it means or how it differs from a traditional conviction. As a Broward County criminal defense attorney, I’ve seen firsthand how this alternative disposition can make a meaningful difference in my clients’ lives.
Understanding Withholding Adjudication
Withholding adjudication is a legal mechanism in Florida that allows a judge to impose a sentence without formally entering a conviction on your record. Essentially, the court accepts your plea (or finds you guilty after trial) but stops short of adjudicating you guilty of the crime. Instead, the judge withholds the adjudication and typically places you on probation with specific conditions you must fulfill.
Think of it as being found responsible for the offense without being formally “convicted” in the traditional sense. While this distinction might seem subtle, it carries significant legal and practical implications that can affect your employment, housing, professional licensing, and other aspects of your life.
When Is Withholding Adjudication Available?
Florida law limits when courts can withhold adjudication. Generally, this option is available for most misdemeanor offenses and certain third-degree felonies. However, Florida Statute 775.08435 specifically prohibits withholding adjudication for serious crimes, including:
- Most violent felonies
- Sexual offenses
- Driving under the influence (DUI) convictions
- Domestic violence charges
- Certain drug trafficking offenses
- Repeat offenses where the defendant has previously received withheld adjudication
The availability of this option often depends on several factors, including the specific charges, your criminal history, the circumstances of the alleged offense, and the prosecutor’s willingness to agree to this disposition. First-time offenders typically have the best chance of receiving withheld adjudication, especially for non-violent crimes.
Why Withholding Adjudication Is Preferable to a Conviction
The primary advantage of withheld adjudication is that you can legally say you have not been “convicted” of the crime in most circumstances. This distinction offers several important benefits:
- Employment Opportunities. Many job applications ask whether you’ve been “convicted” of a crime. With withheld adjudication, you can typically answer “no” to this question, though you should always consult with an attorney about specific situations and be prepared to explain if the arrest shows up on background checks.
- Professional Licensing. Many professional licenses require disclosure of convictions. Withheld adjudication may help you maintain or obtain professional licenses in fields like healthcare, finance, real estate, or law.
- Housing Applications. Landlords often screen for criminal convictions. Withheld adjudication may make it easier to secure housing, though some landlords may still consider arrests or charges.
- Civil Rights. Unlike a felony conviction, withheld adjudication doesn’t result in the loss of civil rights such as voting or firearm ownership (though firearms restrictions may still apply during probation).
- Future Sentencing. If you’re ever charged with a crime in the future, withheld adjudication typically won’t be used to enhance your sentence as a prior conviction would be.
The Reality: You’re Not Off the Hook
While withheld adjudication offers significant advantages over a conviction, it’s crucial to understand that it doesn’t erase the incident from your record or eliminate all consequences. Here’s what you need to know:
Probation Requirements
Withheld adjudication almost always comes with probation, which may include community service, counseling, drug testing, reporting to a probation officer, and payment of fines and costs. Violating probation can result in the court adjudicating you guilty of the original charge.
Public Records
The arrest and court proceedings remain part of the public record. Background checks will still show the arrest and charge, even if they don’t show a conviction.
Limited Expungement Options
While you may be eligible to have your record sealed or expunged after completing probation, this isn’t automatic and requires a separate legal process.
Disclosure Requirements
Certain applications, particularly for government positions, security clearances, or professional licenses, may require disclosure of arrests and charges regardless of the outcome.
Immigration Consequences
For non-citizens, even withheld adjudication can have serious immigration consequences, including deportation or inadmissibility.
Cases Where Withholding Adjudication Is Common
In my Fort Lauderdale practice, I’ve successfully negotiated withheld adjudication for clients facing various charges, including:
- Theft crimes such as shoplifting or petit theft
- Drug possession charges for personal use amounts
- Disorderly conduct and disturbing the peace
- Trespassing violations
- Battery charges in certain circumstances
- Fraud cases involving smaller amounts
- Probation violations in some situations
The key is often demonstrating to the court and prosecutor that you’re unlikely to reoffend and that the circumstances warrant this alternative disposition.
The Negotiation Process
Obtaining withheld adjudication rarely happens automatically. It typically requires skilled negotiation between your defense attorney and the prosecutor. This process involves:
Case Assessment
Your defense attorney will evaluate the strength of the prosecution’s case, identifying weaknesses that might encourage a favorable plea agreement.
Mitigation Presentation
We gather evidence about your character, employment, family situation, and any steps you’ve taken to address underlying issues that may have contributed to the charges.
Prosecutor Negotiations
Experienced defense lawyers in Fort Lauderdale have relationships with local prosecutors and understand what arguments are most likely to succeed in each jurisdiction.
Court Presentation
Even with prosecutorial agreement, the judge must approve any withheld adjudication. Your attorney will present compelling reasons why this disposition serves the interests of justice.
Why Experienced Legal Representation Is Essential
Facing criminal charges can be overwhelming, and the decisions you make early in the process can have lasting consequences. Here’s why hiring an experienced criminal defense lawyer is the most important choice you can make:
Understanding Your Options
The criminal justice system is complex, and many defendants don’t realize alternatives like withheld adjudication exist. An experienced attorney will explain all available options and help you understand the potential consequences of each choice.
Negotiation Skills
Prosecutors are more likely to offer favorable plea agreements to defendants represented by respected defense attorneys. Your lawyer’s reputation and relationships can significantly impact the outcome of your case.
Procedural Knowledge
Criminal procedure involves strict deadlines, complex rules, and specific requirements. Missing a deadline or failing to follow proper procedures can severely damage your case.
Investigation and Discovery
A thorough investigation might reveal evidence that weakens the prosecution’s case or identifies defenses you didn’t know existed. This can provide leverage in negotiations or lead to dismissed charges.
Courtroom Experience
If your case goes to trial, you want an attorney who regularly appears in court and understands how to effectively present your defense to judges and juries.
Long-term Perspective
An experienced criminal attorney will consider not just the immediate consequences of your case but also the long-term impact on your life, career, and future opportunities.
The Process of Obtaining Withheld Adjudication
If you’re eligible for withheld adjudication, the process typically follows these steps:
- Plea Negotiations. Your attorney negotiates with the prosecutor to reach an agreement that includes withheld adjudication.
- Court Appearance. You appear before the judge, who must approve the agreement.
- Plea Entry: You enter a plea of guilty or no contest to the charges.
- Sentence Imposition. The judge imposes a sentence but withholds adjudication, typically placing you on probation.
- Probation Completion. You must successfully complete all terms of probation.
- Record Sealing/Expungement. After completing probation, you may be eligible to have your record sealed or expunged.
Moving Forward After Withheld Adjudication
Successfully obtaining withheld adjudication is just the beginning. To maximize the benefits of this disposition:
- Complete Probation Successfully. Follow all probation requirements exactly. Any violation could result in adjudication of guilt.
- Consider Record Sealing. Once you complete probation, consult with an attorney about sealing or expunging your record.
- Understand Ongoing Limitations. Be aware of situations where you may still need to disclose the arrest or charge.
- Learn from the Experience. Use this opportunity to address any underlying issues that contributed to the charges.
Withholding adjudication can be a valuable tool for minimizing the long-term consequences of criminal charges in Florida. While it’s not available in all cases and doesn’t eliminate all consequences, it can provide a path forward that preserves many opportunities that would be lost with a conviction.
The key to obtaining this favorable outcome is having skilled legal representation from the moment you’re arrested. An experienced criminal defense attorney can evaluate your case, identify the best strategies, and fight for the most favorable outcome possible.
If you’re facing criminal charges in Broward County, don’t wait to seek legal help. The decisions you make now will impact your future for years to come. Contact an experienced criminal defense attorney who can protect your rights and work to minimize the consequences of your arrest.
Remember, every case is unique, and the information in this article is general in nature. The specific facts of your case will determine what options are available to you. Only through a thorough consultation with a qualified attorney can you understand how the law applies to your particular situation and what strategies might be most effective in your defense.
If you have been arrested in Broward County, call The Ansara Law Firm in Fort Lauderdale today for your free initial consultation at (954) 761-4011.
